You may think that a Home Health Aide (HHA) and a Certified Nursing Assistant (CNA) do the same job, but they don’t.
In this guide, we’ll break down the differences between the two of them, so you can make the best decision for your loved one.
If your loved one needs extra support to stay safe and independent at home, contact Premier Home Care today. Our home health aides and non-medical caregivers provide personalized care to help older adults age gracefully in place.
Questions about home care? Check out our videos to learn more.
What Is a Certified Nursing Assistant (CNA)?
Simply put, CNAs and home health aides both support people who need help with daily care, but CNAs complete more formal training and must earn a certification.
Typical CNA Responsibilities Include:
- Performing bedside tasks like changing linens
- Assisting with bed baths and sponge baths
- Helping with mobility, such as getting in and out of bed
- Supporting personal grooming and hygiene
CNAs often work in more clinical settings such as:
- Hospitals
- Skilled nursing facilities (SNFs)
- Independent living communities
- Sometimes even in patients’ homes
A lot of times, there isn’t enough nursing staff on a hospital floor to meet every patient’s needs. CNAs pick up the slack, keeping patients comfortable by helping with:
- Bathroom visits
- Bringing water or meals
- Monitoring patient conditions
What Is a Home Health Aide (HHA)?
A Home Health Aide, sometimes referred to as a DCW (Direct Care Worker), is someone who takes care of individuals in a non-medical or personal care setting. This care usually takes place in the patient’s own home, though it can also be in hospitals or nursing facilities.
Unlike CNAs, HHAs don’t need formal schooling or a license. While there are some certification programs available, they are far shorter and less rigorous than CNA training.
Typical HHA responsibilities include:
- Personal care (bathing, grooming, dressing)
- Light housekeeping
- Meal preparation
- Companionship and daily support
Many HHAs get hired based on relevant life experience. For example, if you’ve taken care of a grandparent or loved one for a few years, that experience may be enough to qualify for a home health aide role.
However, hospitals and skilled nursing facilities typically prefer CNAs for more clinical roles.
Key Differences Between CNAs vs. HHAs
While both CNAs and HHAs care for individuals who need assistance, their level of training, responsibilities, and work environments are very different..
Here’s a quick breakdown to help you understand their roles:
| CNA | HHA | |
| Licensing & Education | State-approved training program + certification exam | Usually no formal license; some certifications or agency training |
| Training | 4–12 week program with classroom + clinical training | Shorter training focused on personal care; sometimes employer-provided |
| Work Setting | Hospitals, nursing homes, rehab centers, assisted living | Primarily private homes |
| Medical Support | Basic clinical tasks like vital signs and patient monitoring | Non-medical care and daily living assistance |
| Pay Scale | Typically higher due to certification and medical duties | Typically lower due to shorter training and non-clinical role |
Licensing & Education
CNA:
- Has to go to school for a lot longer
- Earns a different degree than a home health aide
- Must complete a state-approved training program, which typically includes classroom instruction and hands-on clinical training
- Most CNA programs take 4–12 weeks to complete depending on the school and state requirements
- Must pass a state competency exam to become certified
- Needs to maintain their certification through continuing education or renewal requirements
HHA:
- Doesn’t require going to a formal school or getting a license in many states
- Programs may include instruction on bathing, dressing, mobility assistance, and safety in the home
- Some HHAs complete employer-provided training instead of attending a formal program
- May earn a home health aide certificate, which generally requires fewer hours than CNA training
- If working for a Medicare-certified home health agency, federal guidelines require at least 75 hours of training and a competency evaluation
- Certifications, when required, are usually faster to obtain than CNA certification
Career Path & Advancement
Both CNAs and home health aides can build careers in caregiving, but the training CNAs receive often opens the door to more advanced roles in healthcare.
CNA:
- Can gain experience in hospitals, nursing homes, and rehabilitation centers
- Often use the role as a starting point for higher-level medical careers
- May continue their education to become a Licensed Practical Nurse (LPN) or Registered Nurse (RN)
HHA:
- May pursue additional certifications to expand caregiving skills
- Some HHAs choose to complete CNA training later to expand job opportunities
- Experience as an HHA can be a helpful introduction to the healthcare field
Work Opportunities & Pay Scale
CNA:
- More likely to work in hospitals, skilled nursing facilities, or independent living facilities
- Gets paid more because of the schooling, investment, and time commitment
- Pay varies based on experience, employer, location, and shift differentials, but the average CNA salary in Pennsylvania is about $33,377 per year ($16.05/hour)
HHA:
- Can usually start working immediately if you have relevant experience
- Often hired if you’ve taken care of a family member and can demonstrate the necessary skills
- Typically not hired in hospitals or skilled nursing facilities, as they prefer CNAs
- Pay rates vary based on experience, agency, location, and hours worked, but HHAs in Pennsylvania earn roughly $30,000 per year, or about $14 per hour on average
Scope of Practice: What Each Role Is Allowed to Do
CNAs provide clinical care under nurse supervision, while HHAs focus on personal assistance.
CNAs are licensed to assist with the following:
- Take and record vital signs such as blood pressure, pulse, and temperature
- Assist patients with mobility, transfers, and positioning to prevent injury or bedsores
- Help patients with bathing, dressing, grooming, and toileting
- Observe and report changes in a patient’s condition to nurses or medical staff
- Assist with basic medical tasks under the supervision of a registered nurse or licensed practical nurse
- Support patients in hospitals, nursing homes, rehabilitation centers, and other clinical settings
HHA responsibilities typically include:
- Help clients with personal care tasks such as bathing, dressing, and grooming
- Assist with household activities like meal preparation, light housekeeping, and laundry
- Provide companionship and emotional support
- Help clients move safely around the home and reduce fall risk
- Offer medication reminders (but typically do not administer medication)
- Support individuals who want to live safely and comfortably in their own homes
Hiring a CNA vs. an HHA: Making The Best Choice for Your Loved One
The right caregiver depends on your loved one’s needs.
A CNA may be the best choice if your loved one:
- Requires regular medical care (e.g., monitoring of vital signs, wound care)
- Uses oxygen, feeding tubes, or medical equipment at home
- Has limited mobility and needs advanced assistance
- Is staying in a hospital, skilled nursing facility, or rehab center
An HHA may be suitable if your loved one:
- Needs help with personal care but does not have serious medical conditions
- Requires assistance with meal prep, housekeeping, and companionship
- Wants to stay independent at home but needs some support
- Does not require medical monitoring or skilled nursing
How Are CNAs and HHAs the Same?
HHAs and CNAs have a lot of overlapping roles as well. A lot of these roles involve personal care.
This includes tasks like:
- Bathing
- Grooming
- Dressing
- Helping with Activities of Daily Living (ADLs)
This is all to ensure that your loved one has the highest quality of life. If they can’t perform these tasks by themselves, either a CNA or an HHA can assist them.
Find the Right Caregiver For Your Loved One with Premier Home Care
Your loved one deserves respectful, attentive care, whether they need daily assistance or advanced medical support. Premier Home Care will match them with a home health aide, registered nurse, or non-medical caregiver to keep them safe and comfortable at home.
Contact us today to learn more about our home care services and find the perfect caregiver for your loved one.